Coconut Sugar versus White sugar
Which is the healthier option?
You May be surprised by my response
I read numerous nutrition articles, research articles and health books weekly if not daily. Most of the information is very helpful and informative.
Usually it leads me to ask more questions which then lead me to more research. Along the way I stumble upon some blogs-some very good ones and some really bad ones.
This blog post is created because of a blog I read on “Ways to Alter Recipes to make them Healthier” This was written by someone called “Dr. Donna” but no other information about her was provided.
While the article had many errors (and a few good points) the comment that made me laugh was this:
“Commit to NO sugar in a recipe. You can do this by using coconut sugar instead”
Hmmm, last time I checked coconut SUGAR is still sugar!
What concerns me is that her post has been viewed over 46,000 times in the past year since it was posted! How many of those people now have chronic health conditions due to their “sugarless coconut sugar” eating.
I’m sorry, what did she not understand in the wording “coconut sugar”
I admit that I use coconut sugar in some of my baked good recipes. BUT I would never mislead my guests or clients and say “here, try some of my no sugar added cookies!”
- Some tout coconut sugar to have a lower glycemic index than regular processed/refined white sugar. But if you look at the research, only a couple of studies have been done and on only a handful of people. One study was done by a government that is one of the largest producers of coconut sugar in the world.
- Studies vary saying coconut sugar has a glycemic index anywhere from 35 to 54. (White sugar is around 60). For me, I need to see more research.
- Coconut sugar is higher in some minerals as opposed to white sugar BUT….
- In order to get the nutrient benefits from coconut sugar you would have to eat A LOT of it! Eat whole foods instead.
- Regular table sugar is 50% fructose, 50% glucose. You may see claims that coconut sugar is fructose free but in reality it is roughly 40% fructose. Fructose gets processed by the liver and the excess get stored as fat. Fructose contributes to heart disease, diabetes, obesity and in my opinion, mental health issues and systemic inflammation as well.
- Coconut sugar does contain some inulin which is a prebiotic fiber. Again, how much do you need to consume to reap the benefits? Eat raw onion, raw garlic, raw asparagus and not overly ripe bananas for your prebiotic fiber instead!
- Some coconut sugar products are not 100% coconut sugar but instead a blend with cane sugar. Know your products or ask someone who does know which products to use!
- If you are diabetic you should treat the consumption of coconut sugar the same as consuming refined white sugar.
- While it may be the better choice than white sugar, it can still impact your liver and blood sugar health.
- If you opt for coconut sugar, use it in small, limited quantities, not part of your daily intake.
- It has the same amount of calories as white sugar.
Coconut sugar is still a sugar. It is a better option that GMO white processed sugar for the occasional baked good but don’t be misled. It is still sugar. Use it as an occasional treat instead.
Coconut is a great source for healthy fats but in the form of coconut oil. Fat gives food its flavor. I make banana bread that really does not have any added sugar! What gives it a great taste is the coconut oil and the bananas provide all the sweetness that you need.
There is so much information on the web and unfortunately much of it can do more harm than good. Always check the sources of the information provided and do further research. If you are still unsure, bring the information to a qualified professional in that subject area to get their take on the information.
I always research products and information. Most product companies that stand behind their products and their words are more than happy to respond to you and share more information. I email and call companies all the time!
Sadly (for me, not for her!) there was nowhere to comment at the end of “Dr. Debbie’s” post to let her know of the error but I’m sure she is glad that I was unable to comment!
Bauman, E. & Friedlander, J. (2014) Foundations in Nutrition. CA: Bauman College
Gunnars, K. (nd) Coconut Sugar-Healthy Sugar Alternative or a Big, Fat Lie? https://authoritynutrition.com/coconut-sugar/
Perlmutter, D. (nd) Coconut Palm Sugar-What’s the Skinny? http://www.drperlmutter.com/coconut-palm-sugar-whats-skinny/
Virgin, JJ. (8/18/14) Coconut Sugar: Healthier Sweetener of Another Pretty Name for Sugar? http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jj-virgin/coconut-sugar-healthier-s_b_5669084.html
Karen Brennan, MSW, CNC, Board Certified in Holistic Nutrition (candidate), author of the E book Tru Foods Depression Free Nutrition Guide; How Food Supplements and herbs can be used to lift your mood and owner of Tru Foods Nutrition Services, LLC believes in food first when addressing the root causes to your health conditions. For more information, visit her website at www.trufoodsnutrition.com
As a nutrition professional, Karen Brennan does not treat, cure nor diagnose. This information is for educational purposes only.